Images like the one you shared are popular because they promise simple answers: feel tired → take magnesium; cramps → potassium; anxiety → zinc.
While minerals do play essential roles in health, symptoms are rarely caused by a single deficiency, and self-supplementing without context can sometimes do more harm than good.
This article explains each symptom–mineral link, what science actually supports, and what to do instead.
1. Tired All the Time → Magnesium
Partly true
Magnesium is involved in:
-
Energy production (ATP)
-
Muscle and nerve function
-
Sleep quality
However:
Chronic fatigue is far more commonly caused by:
-
Iron deficiency
-
Poor sleep
-
Stress
-
Thyroid disorders
-
Depression
-
Vitamin B12 deficiency
👉 Magnesium may help if deficient, but fatigue alone is not a reliable indicator.
2. Muscle Cramps → Potassium
Sometimes true
Potassium is crucial for muscle contraction and nerve signals.
But cramps are more often caused by:
-
Dehydration
-
Magnesium deficiency
-
Overuse or muscle fatigue
-
Poor circulation
👉 Potassium deficiency is relatively rare unless there’s vomiting, diarrhea, or diuretic use.
3. Cold Hands & Feet → Iron
Often true
Iron deficiency can reduce oxygen delivery to tissues, leading to:
-
Cold extremities
-
Fatigue
-
Pale skin
Other causes include:
-
Poor circulation
-
Low thyroid function
-
Raynaud’s phenomenon
👉 Iron levels should always be tested before supplementation.
4. Cold Hands & Feet → Calcium
Mostly inaccurate
Calcium deficiency does not typically cause cold extremities.
Calcium is more related to:
-
Bone health
-
Muscle contraction
-
Nerve signaling
5. Weak Bones / Teeth → Magnesium
Partly true
Magnesium helps regulate:
-
Calcium absorption
-
Bone mineral density
But bone weakness is usually due to:
-
Vitamin D deficiency
-
Low calcium intake
-
Hormonal changes
-
Lack of weight-bearing exercise
👉 Bone health depends on multiple nutrients, not magnesium alone.
6. Poor Sleep → Magnesium
Good evidence
Magnesium can:
-
Calm the nervous system
-
Improve sleep quality
-
Reduce nighttime muscle tension
👉 Magnesium glycinate or citrate is commonly used, but sleep issues often have many causes.
7. Brain Fog → Magnesium
Possible but nonspecific
Brain fog can be caused by:
-
Stress
-
Poor sleep
-
Blood sugar fluctuations
-
Iron or B12 deficiency
-
Hormonal imbalance
👉 Magnesium may help indirectly but is not a primary cause.
8. Mood Swings / Anxiety → Zinc
Sometimes true
Zinc plays a role in:
-
Neurotransmitter regulation
-
Immune function
However anxiety is more commonly linked to:
-
Stress
-
Trauma
-
Sleep deprivation
-
Magnesium deficiency
-
Hormonal imbalance
👉 Zinc deficiency is uncommon unless diet is very limited.
9–12. Hormone Balance → Iron, Silica, Copper, Zinc
Highly oversimplified
Hormones are regulated by:
-
Brain (hypothalamus & pituitary)
-
Thyroid
-
Adrenal glands
-
Sex hormones
-
Liver and gut health
While minerals support enzymes involved in hormone production:
-
No single mineral “balances hormones”
-
Excess copper or iron can worsen symptoms
👉 Hormonal symptoms require medical evaluation, not guesswork.
13. Joint Pain → Boron
Emerging but limited evidence
Boron may support:
-
Bone metabolism
-
Inflammation regulation
But joint pain is usually caused by:
-
Osteoarthritis
-
Autoimmune disease
-
Injury
-
Overuse
-
Vitamin D deficiency
👉 Boron is not a primary treatment.
14. Cracked Lips / Mouth Sores → Iron
Sometimes true
More commonly caused by:
-
Vitamin B2 (riboflavin) deficiency
-
B12 deficiency
-
Dehydration
-
Fungal infection
👉 Iron is only one of many possibilities.
15. Brittle Nails → Silica
Weak evidence
Brittle nails are more often linked to:
-
Iron deficiency
-
Biotin deficiency
-
Thyroid issues
-
Excess water exposure
Silica evidence is limited and inconsistent.
16. Insulin Resistance / Sugar Cravings → Chromium
Mixed evidence
Chromium helps insulin function, but:
-
Effects are modest
-
Not a treatment for diabetes
-
Excess chromium can be harmful
👉 Blood sugar control depends more on diet, exercise, sleep, and weight management.
🚨 Why These Charts Are Dangerous If Taken Literally
-
Symptoms overlap across many deficiencies
-
Over-supplementation can cause toxicity
-
Iron, copper, and zinc compete for absorption
-
You may mask serious conditions
✅ What You Should Do Instead
-
Get blood tests before supplementing (iron, B12, vitamin D, magnesium if needed)
-
Fix diet first:
-
Whole foods
-
Protein
-
Vegetables
-
Healthy fats
-
-
Use supplements only when deficient
-
Treat symptoms holistically—not symptom → pill
Final Takeaway
Minerals are supporting players, not magic cures.
Health symptoms are signals from complex systems—not isolated deficiencies.